Policy Experts Submit Report to NATO Secretary General

In March 2014, the secretary general of the North Atlantic Treaty Organization, Anders Fogh Rasmussen, appointed ten independent policy experts to a panel and asked them to provide advice on the future of the transatlantic bond. The panel included a Canadian: CIPS Director Roland Paris.

On June 10, the group presented its report to Secretary-General Rasmussen at the Conference on Strengthening the Trans-Atlantic Bond in Brussels.

Collective Defence and Common Security:

Twin Pillars of the Atlantic Alliance 

Read the report (6 pages, PDF)

Executive Summary

  • Transatlantic security cannot be taken for granted. Following its withdrawal from Afghanistan, NATO needs to reaffirm its value around the twin objectives of collective defence and common security.

Pillar I: Upholding peace and stability in Europe

  • The commitment under NATO’s Article V to treat an attack against one as an attack against all must be credible, and NATO members should take concrete steps together to make it so. Tallinn should be as secure as Toronto.
  • There can be no return to a ‘strategic partnership’ between NATO and Russia so long as Russia’s actions threaten European security.
  • European governments bear particular responsibility for ensuring their own territorial security. They must invest in the necessary R&D, equipment and deployable capabilities. No amount of ‘smarter’ defence will compensate for a failure to reverse falling defence spending.
  • NATO needs to develop effective responses to the ‘non-linear’ forms of aggression seen during the crisis in Ukraine. But the EU should take the lead in helping its members and neighbours embed good governance practices that will lessen their vulnerability to external destabilization.
  • European countries should reduce their dependence on Russian energy. Russia’s main strength should no longer be Europe’s main vulnerability.
  • NATO’s door should remain open to all European democracies that share the values of the Alliance. However, existing members must be ready, willing and able to extend the full benefits of Alliance membership to them, including those in Article V.

Pillar II: Confronting international insecurity

  • NATO should not turn inwards after 2014. Much of the Middle East, and North Africa face a decade of turmoil which will pose direct threats to NATO members.
  • In Asia, unresolved territorial disputes and historical animosities are driving dramatic rises in defence spending. It must be remembered that the Pacific Ocean is the western flank of NATO.
  • In this context, it should not be left to the United States and a handful of others to deploy hard power beyond NATO’s borders. An over-reliance on US power projection will erode the foundations of the transatlantic bond over time.
  • NATO and the EU must also cooperate closely to deliver their comprehensive range of capabilities to manage international crises, from market access and development assistance to military intervention and post-conflict civilian support.
  • Completion of the Transatlantic Trade and Investment Partnership (TTIP) and Canada-EU Trade Agreement (CETA) will strengthen the transatlantic community strategically as well as economically.
  • NATO needs to differentiate its approach to working with its international partners. In particular, it should develop long-term cooperative arrangements with the small number of countries in Europe and beyond which have contributed actively alongside NATO to international security in recent years.
  • The NATO–Russia Council should continue to operate at ambassadorial and higher levels. This will help the two sides coordinate responses to international crises and potentially rebuild trust on European security.
  • NATO publics are increasingly sceptical about the value of any form of external intervention. Political leaders need to communicate better the deterioration of the security situation in Europe; the importance of international security to their nations’ welfare and prosperity; and the need to protect the core values that underpin the Alliance, especially democratic governance, open economies and the rule of law.

Report Authors

  • Martin Butora, Honorary President of the Institute of Public Affairs, Bratislava
  • lvo Daalder, President, Chicago Council on Global Affairs, Chicago, and former US ambassador to NATO
  • Camille Grand, Director of the Fondation pour la Recherche Strategique, Paris
  • Robin Niblett, Director of Chatham House, London
  • Ana Palacio, former Minister of Foreign Affairs of Spain and member of the Consejo de Estado of Spain
  • Roland Paris, Director of the Centre for International Policy Studies, University of Ottawa
  • Volker Perthes, Director of the Stiftung Wissenschaft und Politik, Berlin
  • Nathalie Tocci, Deputy Director, lstituto Affari lnternazionali, Rome
  • Sinan Ulgen, Director of Center for Economics and Foreign Policy Studies, Istanbul
  • Marcin Zaborowski, Director of Polish Institute for International Affairs, Warsaw

Read the report (6 pages, PDF)

Related Articles

Authors

The CIPS Blog is written only by subject-matter experts. For a list of our authors, please click here.